It's possible I might have sidestepped the rocket. But is strafing still possible on AoMC, is the 98% chance to hit only the starting value and do dodging bonuses come after that?
This was on HNTR.
For comparison, on a later standard, non-AoMC HMP game Cybie took 7 BFG shots to kill on P1-modded BFGs. That's on average like 350 damage. But then in the HNTR AoMC game I supposedly had to hit him with 6*10*8=480 damage to kill him. It seems more likely to me that the BFG hits were actually doing randomized damage each about the average 40 for a BFG depleting his alleged 200 hp in six shots.
Also think of the damage cybie dealt me with those two hits. 36, so 18 each hit, sounds more like average damage than maxed damage to me (the wiki lists his damage as 6d6).
So it looks like the Max Carnage rules aren't enforced in the fight against Cybie. I think this ought to be changed, it'd make for a fun if short fight. Better hit him fast and hard or he'll kill you in two hits.