DRL > Requests For Features

critical hits

(1/2) > >>

xenozid:
imo every good RPG needs criticals (for all the ninjas and snipers out there) so hereŽs my idea for doomRL.
maybe enemys shouldnŽt be able to hit you critically, UV and N! games would be TOO random otherwise. iŽd suggest the average player starts with 5% crit. chance and to increase it youŽd have to get some kind of trait. maybe thereŽs 3 of them increasing the chance for 15% resulting in 50% crit.chance. or maybe 2 with 20% resulting in 45% crit.chance. and after "critical hit chance trait lvl 2" there could be a trait to increase the dmg. dealt per critical... (leading to some kind of sharpshooter master trait with EE3 or INT1)
...about the dmg. boost per critical...maybe 20% ? too much ? not enough ? dunno...
...maybe we need a new weapon class "rifle" for this to work because i think rockets could potentially break this, so this critical thing only works with pistols and rifles.

hope you like, discuss, i really think the whole space marine setting needs some sniper option ^^

raekuul:
Not a bad concept, but the implementation suggested would make the game waaaaaaaaaay too easy.

Rather than extra damage, how about a critical shot ignores armor?

Since Shotguns already get MAD, and Plasma-based weaponry cuts armor in half anyway (what does the fire-type do to armor?), this would be restricted to melee, pistols (not blaster), and chaingun - basically, any P-type weapon that uses Kinetic ammo.

A base 5% chance to ignore armor, plus a mid-game 2-level trait (requiring what? SoG2?) that improves critical chance by 2%, leading to a maximum 10% chance of ignoring armor altogether.

Also, the sniper option? Use the alt-fire on your starting weapon.

Jarkko:
Ignoring armour is a weak effect affecting only monsters and players using pistols or rockets.

I'd vote for base 5% chance for you and the monsters to do double damage and a base level two-tier trait giving a further +15% for a maximum of 35%. This "Lucky bastard" trait would then unlock "Jinxed" giving you a further +50% chance for 85% total chance of double damage but would also set the critical chance for monsters to 50%!

5% base so it doesn't affect the normal playing too much. 15% increases so the trait is at least somewhat useful.* The Jinxed trait for shits and giggles.

*Compare to SoBx3 which doubles plasma rifle damage against B's, A's, M's and V's.

Frankosity:
I don't like the ideas of criticals because they make the game more random than it should be. Compared to Nethack and it's ilk, DoomRL is at its heart an intensely tactical game, and the chance of getting wiped out by a lucky volley from an Arachnotron or Arch-vile compromises that, in my opinion.

I'd go so far as to say that I think the whole damage dice system should be thrown out in favour of a static damage rating for each weapon, but I doubt it's a popular enough idea to be implemented.

raekuul:

--- Quote from: Frankosity on November 17, 2009, 08:06 ---I don't like the ideas of criticals because they make the game more random than it should be. Compared to Nethack and it's ilk, DoomRL is at its heart an intensely tactical game, and the chance of getting wiped out by a lucky volley from an Arachnotron or Arch-vile compromises that, in my opinion.
--- End quote ---

That's exactly why I suggested that a critical hit be an armor-piercing blow rather than actual damage added to the damage roll.

I can see it now - Scoring a piercing blow that deals (dramatic pause) one damage.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page