DoomRL > Discussion

Tactical Armour OP?

(1/2) > >>

2birds1stone:
Okay, so from what I can gather, it used to be worse than it is now, but it's still pretty overpowered, and the problem comes about as a combination of factors.

1) Speed-built characters never need fear a monster again if they get Tac Armour; characters not built for speed are still doing ridiculously well with this, and probably don't have much to fear either.
2) It's assembled from three common drops, all of which drop from very early in the game.
3) It regenerates.

Point one is a characteristic shared with Phaseshift, but Phaseshift remains balanced by not being something you can rely on, and by punishing the player for sleep-deprived mistakes; you can screw up pretty monumentally with Tactical Armour, and it's okay, because you can retreat without being hit and your armour regenerates itself as if nothing happened. If you make a sleep-deprived mistake with Phaseshift, it may well be gone.

Point two is a simple case of "items should be balanced to their obtainance difficulty". Tactical Armour is very much an I-win card for certain builds, and it's still a highly viable option for everything except Entrenchment.

Point three was covered in point one; while Phaseshift is just as bad, if not worse, than Tac Armour, it forces you to keep your head and play sanely, it does not hold your hand and say "aww, you got shot, here, let me make it better for you".

Were I to nerf Tactical Armour, I'd remove regeneration, and maybe make it a Green + (A3) Advanced Assembly; the latter would be nice, but possibly overkill.

Uh, thoughts?

Fanta Hege:
It's not really that OP with the 0 protection it gives you. (or 2 if you power mod it after whizkid2, but you'll probably want A mod it for maximun speed anyway)

In the later levels the lack of protection will screw you over and even with the regen, it'll be roasted in no time when you take damage due of all the heavy hitters that later levels start to give out on you.
While as it is nice with the whole GOTTAGOFAST it's usualy better to safe that for boots and leave your armor for the armor uses.

It is a risk vs reward armor. Sure it might feel OP but trust me, the first time you run into a surprise mancubi pack, you really wish you would've used a modded red armor instead.

thelaptop:
The next thing you're going to say that the Inquisitor set is OP.  >.>

But yes, Tactical Armour's greatest failing is that it will be destroyed very quickly when Mancubi, Revenants and Barons start coming en masse.  You are basically naked, and the regeneration is not instantaneous -- there is a delay before the regeneration kicks in.

I don't think it is OP enough to be pushed into being an Advanced Assembly.

Sereg:
Movespeed != immunity from damage. Yeah, it's a nice piece of gear, and maybe it's a little on the strong side for a basic assembly, but I'd hardly call it OP - most games I don't even bother to build it. As has been said, 0 protection is pretty painful.

2birds1stone:

--- Quote from: Fanta Hege on June 15, 2013, 07:11 ---Sure it might feel OP but trust me, the first time you run into a surprise mancubi pack, you really wish you would've used a modded red armor instead.
--- End quote ---
I'm no stranger to surprise Mancubi, and I admit to keeping Fireproof Red armour on standby in case of emergency, but that regen really does strike me as ridiculous.

Eh, apparently I'm outnumbered and unsupported here, the regen really does feel ridiculous to me, but I may well change my mind after playing more Nightmare!.

I gotta concede that zero protection is a someone significant downside.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page