Chaosforge Forum

General => Discussion => Topic started by: thelaptop on June 30, 2012, 10:55

Title: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: thelaptop on June 30, 2012, 10:55
Okay folks!  The last big release was good ol' DoomRL, all spruced up with new stuff.  But we hunger for more, don't we?  Let's give some feedback to Kornel on the next RL that he should make a release of next here.

Comments, discussion are all welcome (as always).

Poll is going to run for 30 days.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: skarczew on June 30, 2012, 11:34
I voted for AliensRL, but I would like to mention about DiabloRL as well.

Both games had their (somewhat) stable releases years ago, both of them got tons of bugs and issues reported.
Now (actually, this should be done ~2 years ago ;) ) it is the time to do sth with it.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: thelaptop on June 30, 2012, 12:05
Well to be had, development on DiabloRL and AliensRL have not ceased, it's just that they have been quite "in-the-background" without actually seeing a release.

So this poll is not so much as a "work on which RL next" poll, but a "release which RL next" one.

I hope the distinction is clearer?  Hahahaha...
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Sanctus on June 30, 2012, 12:39
We need release of DoomRL, and only after DRL1.0 it's make sense to work on other releases
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: you on June 30, 2012, 12:54
DiabloRL or nothing! This world is missing good Diablo-themed games.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Klear on June 30, 2012, 13:51
Voted Aliens, since I really want to like that game, and it will be easier with a better version =)

I also just realized that I'd love to see that hypothetical Roadside Picnic / Stalker RL Kornel mentioned somewhere.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: ParaSait on June 30, 2012, 16:43
Genrogue!!!!!11
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Uranium on June 30, 2012, 16:55
Genrogue!!!!!11
oh no he di-int
Voted for DoomRL because it's the one I play most.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: LuckyDee on July 01, 2012, 02:19
Voted for DoomRL because it's the one I play most.

Was in doubt as to what to vote until I read this. Although I'd probably learn to appreciate the other RLs, I'm sticking to Doom; I can't imagine the others being more appealing to me, and with the discussions going on on the forum, there's a lot of great ideas still to be implemented.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Sanctus on July 01, 2012, 04:56
I also just realized that I'd love to see that hypothetical Roadside Picnic / Stalker RL Kornel mentioned somewhere.

It would be awesome.
But im afraid that original (Roadside) cannot be base for RL. There were no fights, no monsters and so.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Klear on July 01, 2012, 05:04
It would be awesome.
But im afraid that original (Roadside) cannot be base for RL. There were no fights, no monsters and so.

That's what I like about the idea. Make it somehow that you'd have to avoid the traps and weird phenomena instead of shooting you way though the zone. No idea how exactly it would work, but it sounds lovely.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: skarczew on July 01, 2012, 17:53
Well to be had, development on DiabloRL and AliensRL have not ceased, it's just that they have been quite "in-the-background" without actually seeing a release.

So this poll is not so much as a "work on which RL next" poll, but a "release which RL next" one.

I hope the distinction is clearer?  Hahahaha...
Well, unless AliensRL development had been hidden from the beta testers, there were no distinctive changes for ...7 months. And the last alpha version is unplayable, so releasing it would be a bad move now. It needs the work to be done.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: S.K. Ren on July 01, 2012, 19:45
I vote other :P

KK's choice... but personally I'd like to see something to do with exploring a realistically sized city (As in Buildings are the same size inside and out). Think of it as practice for more creative map generating.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Tavana on July 02, 2012, 03:12
Well, unless AliensRL development had been hidden from the beta testers, there were no distinctive changes for ...7 months. And the last alpha version is unplayable, so releasing it would be a bad move now. It needs the work to be done.

Do you lurk on the Chaosforge IRC channel? You can see code commits happen there if you hang around, so you can see the work that happens.

For reference, the most recent SVN revision of AliensRL happened on the 18th of June, just a couple weeks ago.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: skarczew on July 02, 2012, 07:06
Do you lurk on the Chaosforge IRC channel? You can see code commits happen there if you hang around, so you can see the work that happens.

For reference, the most recent SVN revision of AliensRL happened on the 18th of June, just a couple weeks ago.
No, I do not lurk - though I should =( .
But it is always good to hear that some work is being done :) !
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Kashi on July 02, 2012, 12:07
I vote for BerserkRL. Yeah, all others could be interesting, and all that, but it's been a long time since Berserk was in the spotlight, and in my honest opinion, shouldn't be left in the dark.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Motorheadbanger on July 02, 2012, 13:58
Metalheads vote for Diablo to be slain.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: ZicherCZ on July 03, 2012, 01:28
Metalheads vote for Diablo to be slain.
Metalheads vote for Diablo to RULE THE WORLD! /m\
(voted for DiabloRL)
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: ZZ on July 03, 2012, 12:37
While last release of DiabloRl and AliensRL was about a year before, the release of BerserkRL was much earlier. And this game has more potential to be different from "classiacal" roguelikes.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Kornel Kisielewicz on July 03, 2012, 15:22
Wow, there's a lot more love for the other CF roguelikes than I expected... which makes me happy :'-)
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Klear on July 05, 2012, 06:22
The main reason I didn't vote for DoomRL is that I'd hate to lose my hard-earned diamonds now that I have them =)
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Sum Gai on July 06, 2012, 12:48
Doom RL. Ideally with some method of retaining rank earned in the previous release.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: thelaptop on July 06, 2012, 15:00
Doom RL. Ideally with some method of retaining rank earned in the previous release.
Eh?  Rank is related to badges, and since the badges were reworked, they didn't quite carry over exactly.

Hopefully the badge requirements are fixed by now.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: thelaptop on July 07, 2012, 11:26
Don't forget, voting ends on July 30.  Your vote is important because it gives Kornel valuable community feedback on what the community wants.  It is not binding (of course), but it will be taken seriously as the voice of the community.

So if you haven't voted yet, please do!  There's ample time to do it.

=)
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Kornel Kisielewicz on July 07, 2012, 19:13
Don't forget, voting ends on July 30.  Your vote is important because it gives Kornel valuable community feedback on what the community wants.  It is not binding (of course), but it will be taken seriously as the voice of the community.
QFT. Indeed it will!

Next DoomRL release will happen on it's own schedule, but the priority between the others here is a very important factor for me!
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: thelaptop on July 19, 2012, 07:38
Roughly 11 more days before this poll closes.  If you haven't voted, you should vote soon.

=)
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: Motorheadbanger on July 19, 2012, 12:41
DI-AB-LO!! DI-AB-LO!!
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: zchris13 on July 25, 2012, 15:56
I'm voting for AliensRL. It shows so much promise right now, it just needs some love.  I need to try out DiabloRL and BerserkRL, because I haven't yet.
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: thelaptop on July 25, 2012, 18:23
To those who have voted: much thanks!  To the rest...

~5 Days Left!

Give your feedback before it is too late.  >.<
Title: Re: Next RL release (2nd half 2012 edition)?
Post by: thelaptop on July 31, 2012, 10:32
Voting is now closed!  Thanks for all who voted.

According to the response, DoomRL is in the lead (but Kornel says that runs on its schedule).

In decreasing order of preference for the next RL release are: AliensRL, DiabloRL and BerserkRL.

Be assured that the preferences are being taken into consideration.  Even as I am writing this, we already have a BETA version of AliensRL released for testing for all supporters and AliensRL beta testers.  So, if you'd like to help with making a new AliensRL, donate to be a supporter and join in the BETA testing over here (http://forum.chaosforge.org/index.php/topic,5878.0.html).

Ed: Thread locked -- thanks for participation.